Retaking the Senate in 2018 was always a tough climb for Democrats because they are defending 10 seats in states that Donald Trump won in 2016. But that difficult terrain is looking a little less daunting these days, as new polling has led some election forecasters to believe several of those states are actually quite safely in Democratic hands.
Over the past few weeks, Democrats seem to have shored up their positions in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH) has a double-digit polling lead on his Republican opponent; Sen. Bob Casey (D-PA) was always the favorite but now appears absolutely safe; and Sen. Tammy Baldwin (D-WI) — maybe the most vulnerable of the bunch and up for her first reelection in a state Republicans had been dominating — also seems to be on solid ground.
It’s a sign of the times: After two new polls found Brown leading Republican Rep. Jim Renacci by 17 points, the University of Virginia’s Crystal Ball moved Ohio to Likely Democrat. On Thursday, they moved Pennsylvania to Safe Democrat after another pair of polls put Casey up by double digits over Republican Rep. Lou Barletta.
The biggest surprise might be Baldwin’s apparent security. As I previously explained, there was reason to think the first-term senator could be in trouble in Wisconsin, a state where the GOP has solidified control of the state government and made ousting Baldwin a top priority. Indeed, Gov. Scott Walker’s Republican allies had already spent $8.5 million against her in March.
But given the strong showing for Democrats in several special elections in the Badger State and new surveys that have shown Baldwin leading her potential opponents by 9 points or more, Baldwin is looking strong. Wisconsin is now a Likely Democratic win, according to the Crystal Ball’s Kyle Kondik:
This tracks with other signs. Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell did not include Wisconsin in his list of battleground states in an interview with the Washington Post. And Politico’s Burgess Everett detailed recently how the Senate seems to be shrinking in favor of Democrats:
Democrats are still at a disadvantage in trying to flip the 51-49 Senate. They have only two obvious opportunities to flip Republican-held seats — Nevada and Arizona — and they also have very vulnerable incumbents of their own in Missouri, Indiana, North Dakota, and West Virginia. Florida, where Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson is facing a well-funded campaign from two-term Gov. Rick Scott, also can’t be taken for granted. The polling there suggests a very close race.
But, given the terrain they were facing, the latest trends in the Rust Belt are a good sign for Democrats if they’re going to pull off the unlikely.
“Republicans remain favorites to hold the Senate after the 2018 election in November,” Kondik wrote, “although there is a narrow path for Democrats to take the majority.”